Battle for Your Kitchen: Air Fryer vs Grill

“As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.”

Do you love grilled food but don’t have access to an electric grill? Or you’re looking for a way to reduce the amount of oil used when cooking. In either case, an air fryer might be just what you need.

There’s nothing quite like the taste of food cooked on a grill. The smoky flavor is unique and delicious, and grilling is a fun way to cook.

But lately, air fryers have been getting much attention as a healthier alternative to deep frying. So, what’s the verdict? Is grilling better than air frying?

Here are a few reasons why grilling is better than air frying:

  • Grilling retains more nutrients. When you cook food in an air fryer, some of the nutrients are lost in the cooking process. However, grilling helps to keep more nutrients, making your food healthier overall.
  • Grilling gives food a unique flavor. As I mentioned, grilling imparts a delicious smoky flavor you can’t get from an air fryer.

But the debate is not as cut and dry as it might seem. Some benefits make the air fryers stand out over the grills.

  • Air fryers cook food more evenly than grills. With an air fryer, the hot air circulates the food, cooking it evenly. When grilling, you have to be careful not to overcook the outside of your food while the inside remains raw.
  • An air fryer is a way to go if you’re trying to cook healthier. Air fryers require less oil than grills. You can use less oil and still get that crispy, delicious flavor you love.

Comparing the cooking time of each appliance is problematic, as it relies heavily on a recipe and skill.

Air fryer vs grill – the need for oil

There are many differences between the two appliances. Still, one of the most notable is that electric grills require oil to cook food.

On the other hand, air fryers do not use any oil. Air fryers use hot air to cook food, so their versatility is much higher, as you can make recipes that do not require oil.

Most people don’t have outdoor grills and may want to avoid setting up an indoor grill, too. The main difference between these appliances is that you don’t need oil to cook in an air fryer.

Electric grills, on the other hand, require oil to cook food. Air fryers are also much smaller than indoor grills. They are often about the size of a bread box, so you can easily store them in an out-of-the-way place when not in use.

Cuisinart CGPR-221 Cast Iron Grill Press (Wood Handle), Weighs 2.8-pounds

Air fryer vs Grill: Grill marks

Grill marks are one of those things that can make or break a grilled meal. They add a touch of flavor and char that can elevate the dish. But achieving the perfect grill mark can be challenging. Here are a few tips to help you get grill marks that impress your guests.

On the grill, it is an easy task. But you might want to stick to these tips to achieve excellent grill marks every time.

  1. Make sure your grill is hot before you start cooking. The ideal temperature is between 400 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
  2. Place your food on the grill perpendicular to the grates. This will help create those evenly spaced crosshatch marks.
  3. Please don’t move the food around too much once it’s on the grill. Let it cook for a minute or two before flipping it over. Resist the urge to press down on the food with a spatula, as this will squish all those precious juices.

If you can’t grill but still want those grill marks on your air-fried meat, an air fryer grilling pan is a good choice. They’re also great for making grilled cheese sandwiches and French toast in your air fryer.

Air fryer grilling pans allow you to add flavor, texture, and marks without adding oil. The nonstick coating makes it easy to clean up after cooking too.

An air fryer grilling pan is excellent if you’re looking for a new way to enjoy your favorite foods. This tool allows you to cook with the same results as in an outdoor grill but with less fat and calories.

Air fryer vs Grill: Hot air vs Heat and oil

An air fryer is a versatile kitchen appliance that looks like a small deep fryer but uses hot air and circulating fans instead of oil to cook your food. 

They are compact and take up less space than an oven, making them perfect for small kitchens or apartments.

Air fryers use a patented technology called “rapid convection” to cook food in hot air at constant temperatures, which means they will never burn your food as grills do! 

This allows you to prepare foods with crispy textures without the calories and fat commonly associated with cooking foods in oil.

Another great benefit of using an air fryer is its ability to produce consistent results without any guesswork, making preparing meals much easier!

Many people are worried that using an air fryer will reduce the nutritional value of their food, but this is not the case. 

The FDA has approved this technology as a safe way to prepare foods. 

The circulating hot air used in an air fryer gently cooks your food from all sides at once, which means it doesn’t need any oil for cooking and can still maintain its vitamins and minerals.

The best part is you can use an air fryer to make a wide variety of foods, including French fries, chicken wings, fish fillets, pizza, and more! 

You can cook multiple items at once by placing them in separate layered baskets. This will save you time because you don’t have to wait for each item to cook individually.

Air fryer vs Grill: What can they cook?

Grill

While many think of grilling as a way to cook meats, a wide variety of foods can be cooked on a grill. With a little creativity, you can turn your grill into a versatile cooking tool that can help you create healthy and delicious meals.

Here are some ideas for foods that can be cooked on a grill:

  • Vegetables: grilled vegetables are an excellent option for those looking for a healthy and flavorful meal. Grill up some zucchini, eggplant, peppers, and onions for a veggie kabob, or cut them into thin slices and grill them as pizza toppings.
  • Fruit: fruit is another great option for the grill. Sliced peaches, nectarines, and pineapple all make great additions to grilled chicken or fish.

Air Fryer

With an air fryer, there are no limits on what kind of cuisine (or dessert!) you want to try out in the kitchen. The air fryer’s small size makes it perfect for making small meals like appetizers and snacks. You can also use them with other appliances like slow cookers if you want more variety in preparing your food.

The air fryer doesn’t use oil, making it a healthier alternative for cooking food at home. You can plug it in and start cooking! It’s also easier to use than a grill, so you won’t have to learn how to use it.

You can also use an air fryer to make delicious desserts like fried banana chips and other treats. Check my other comparison article here if you are interested in using your air fryer as a dehydrator. It will help you to decide which one you should choose.

An important note is that almost every recipe can be changed to fit any kitchen appliance. For example, cooking a roast in an air fryer is possible, but the results are not the best, and you will be better off using a grill. But from my experience, there are better solutions.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Monument Grills Larger 4-Burner Propane Gas Grills Black Porcelain Enamel Coated Cabinet Style with LED Controls, Clear View Lid, Side Burner, Built in Thermometer, and USB Light

Gas Grills

Propane and natural gas are the most common fuel sources for gas grills, and they each have their benefits. Propane is more portable, so it’s perfect for taking on camping trips or to the beach.

Natural gas is less expensive and produces fewer emissions, making it a more environmentally-friendly option. You should know a few things about gas grills, whether you are a beginner or a grilling pro.

When choosing a gas grill, size is a crucial factor to consider. You’ll need a bigger grill with more burners if you plan on entertaining large groups of people. But a smaller grill will do the trick if you’re only cooking for a few people at a time.

The most notable pros and cons of gas grills are:

Pros: 

  1. They cook food quickly.
  2. They can be used to cook a variety of food.
  3. They are easy to use.
  4. They are portable.
  5. They are relatively inexpensive.

Cons: 

  1. They can be dangerous if not used properly.
  2. They can be challenging to clean.
  3. They can be messy.
  4. They can produce smoke and fumes.
  5. They can be affected by weather conditions.

Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Searing Grill with Adjustable Temperature Control to 450F, Removable Nonstick Grate, 118 sq. in. Surface Serves 6, Stainless Steel

Electric Grills

Electric grills are popular because they are easy to use and can be used indoors or outdoors. There are many different types of electric grills available on the market, so choosing one that will suit your needs is essential. Here are a few things to keep in mind when selecting an electric grill:

Size: The grill will determine how much food you can cook at once. If you have a large family or entertain often, you will need a larger grill.

Features: Some electric grills come with features such as temperature control and timers. These can be helpful if you want to make sure your food is cooked perfectly every time.

Price: Electric grills range from around $30 to $300. Finding one that fits your budget and has the features you want is essential.

The most notable pros and cons of electric grills are:

Pros: 

  1. You can cook indoors without making a mess.
  2. They heat up quickly and evenly.
  3. They are easy to clean.
  4. You can cook a variety of foods on them.
  5. They are portable.

Cons: 

  1. They can be more expensive than other types of grills.
  2. Some people feel food could taste better when cooked on an electric grill.
  3. They can be challenging to store.
  4. You need to have access to an outlet to use them.
  5. They can be less durable than other types of grills.

Ninja DZ201 Foodi 8 Quart 6-in-1 DualZone 2-Basket Air Fryer with 2 Independent Frying Baskets, Match Cook & Smart Finish to Roast, Broil, Dehydrate & More for Quick, Easy Meals, Grey

Air Fryers

An air fryer is a kitchen appliance that cooks food by circulating hot air around it. It’s similar to a convection oven but uses less energy and heats up faster. Air fryers are also small and compact, so they take up less counter space than a traditional oven.

So, what are the benefits of using an air fryer? Check the list below.

Pros: 

  1. Air fryers cook food quickly and evenly.
  2. Air fryers do not require preheating.
  3. Air fryers do not produce smoke or odors.
  4. Air fryers are easy to clean.
  5. Air fryers are small and take up little counter space.

Cons: 

  1. Some air fryers require cooking oil, which can add calories to food.
  2. Some air fryers do not have temperature controls, so that that food can be overcooked or burnt. 
  3. Some air fryers have a short lifespan and break easily.
  4. Air fryers can be expensive.
  5. Air fryers can be noisy.

Air fryers vs Grills: Cleaning

Grills

Whether you’re firing up the grill for a Fourth of July barbecue or just a weeknight dinner, nothing beats the taste of grilled food. But before enjoying any grilled goodness, you have to clean the grill. And that’s sometimes more challenging than it sounds.

One thing that is usually omitted in cleaning is the drip tray. Comparably between air fryers and grills is a considerable difference.

Air fryers are smaller, and their tray is right under the basket, so any moisture, bits, and oil goes straight in, and its size is the same as the basket for ingredients.

Grills are usually much more prominent, and so is their drip tray. And not only the tray but also the tilted sides guide the juices and oils into the tray. So in most cases, the cleaning is extended by a need to clean it after each use.

Here are a few tips to get your grill clean and ready for another grilling session:

  1. Start with a fire. 
  2. Use a wire brush to scrub the grates. Remember to brush in between the spaces! This will help burn off any built-up residue from previous cookouts.
  3. Rinse the grates with warm water when you’re finished scrubbing. 
  4. For more strenuous cleaning jobs, try mixing baking soda and vinegar.

Air fryers

I have already written an in-depth and comprehensive guide on cleaning an air fryer, which you can find here. So I am not going to go too deep here.

If you don’t clean your air fryer, it will eventually start to smoke and smell. You only need a damp cloth and soap to clean your air fryer.

Here’s how to do it:

  1. Unplug the air fryer and let it cool down.
  2. Remove the basket and shake out any loose food.
  3. Wipe down the inside of the air fryer with a damp cloth. Be sure to get the area around the heating element.
  4. Wash the basket in warm, soapy water. Rinse it well and dry it before putting it back in the air fryer.
  5. Wipe down the outside of the air fryer with a damp cloth.

Conclusion

Both the air fryer and the electric grill have their advantages and disadvantages. An air fryer is an excellent alternative if you can’t use your grill. However, an electric grill will be best if you want traditional grilled foods like steaks or burgers.

Vojta Vevera

Combining a love for cooking and using all kinds of technological gizmos helps Vojta to bring the experiences and excitement to all his articles. He is always doing his best to serve you with great information. Mixing over 15 years of cooking experience with his analytical mind and love for all technological things.

Recent Posts