Battle for Your Kitchen: Air Fryer vs Toaster Oven




Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

Are you torn between buying an air fryer or a toaster oven? Both are countertop appliances, but they function differently and have unique features.

The debate on which one is better has been ongoing among kitchen enthusiasts.

This blog post will explore the differences between air fryers and toaster ovens regarding their cooking mechanism, capacity, energy efficiency, and price.

We will also discuss the pros and cons of using each appliance to help you make an informed decision.

So whether you’re aiming for crispy food or heating results, keep reading to determine which appliance suits your needs best!

Understanding The Differences Between Air Fryers And Toaster Ovens

Air fryers and toaster ovens differ in their cooking mechanism, capacity, energy efficiency, and price.

Cooking Mechanism

Regarding the cooking mechanisms, air fryers and toaster ovens differ in how they produce heat.

Air fryers use forced-air convection technology that circulates hot air around the food, providing even heating and producing crispy results without using oil.

On the other hand, toaster ovens use conventional or infrared heating elements for cooking food.

The heating elements may also include a fan for more even cooking, but they do not provide the same level of circulation as air fryers.

The difference in cooking mechanism affects your food’s texture and taste. Air fryers create a crisp exterior while keeping the inside moist and juicy.

Toaster ovens can also produce this effect with some foods like cookies or pizza but aren’t as effective when creating moisture-filled dishes such as roast chicken.

Ultimately, your preference will determine which appliance is best suited for you based on what food you enjoy most frequently.

Consider whether having crispy or moist textured foods is essential when choosing between an air-fryer and a toaster oven before deciding which would suit you best!


When it comes to cooking capacity, air fryers typically have a smaller size compared to toaster ovens.

Air fryers are ideal for small families or individuals who don’t need to cook large meals. On the other hand, most toaster ovens come with larger cooking space and multiple racks, allowing you to cook larger batches of food quickly.

This makes them perfect for families or individuals who enjoy hosting dinner parties.

Cooking Surface Area

Air fryers usually have one cooking basket that can fit limited amounts of food. At the same time, toaster ovens offer more flexible options, such as baking sheets and additional trays, making them an excellent choice when preparing diverse meals.

As such, if you plan on cooking several foods simultaneously or looking into meal prep options, a toaster oven may cater better to your needs.

Overall, determining which appliance has the suitable capacity for your needs will depend on your lifestyle and home situation – whether you prefer smaller appliances that do not take up much kitchen countertop space but limit cooking quantity versus bulkier ones that allow multi-functional use but eat up workspace real estate.

Energy Efficiency

When it comes to energy efficiency, air fryers are the clear winner. They use a combination of convection and radiant heat for cooking food quickly and evenly.

They can cook up to 30% faster than conventional ovens, which means less time cooking and more energy savings. Plus, since they require little or no preheating, you won’t waste extra energy waiting for them to warm up.

On the other hand, toaster ovens tend to use more energy due to their larger size and longer cooking times. However, some models offer features like automatic shut-off or power-saving modes that can help conserve electricity.

It’s important to consider how often you’ll be using your appliance and choose one that meets your cooking needs and budget while being environmentally friendly.


Regarding price, air fryers are generally more expensive than toaster ovens.

However, this is not always the case, as different models and brands are available in the market.

Generally, an average air fryer can cost around $100, while a toaster oven can cost between $40 to $80.

Higher-end models of both appliances can also have varying prices depending on their features and capabilities.

Evaluating your budget and needs before purchasing any kitchen appliance is essential to get value for your money.

Pros And Cons Of Using An Air Fryer

There are many reasons to love an air fryer, including healthier cooking, faster cooking times, and versatile options.

However, it has drawbacks, such as limited capacity and cleaning requirements.

Keep reading to learn more about the pros and cons of using an air fryer!

Pros: Healthier, Faster, and more Versatile Cooking

I love using an air fryer for cooking. One of the most significant advantages is that it provides a healthier cooking option.

Using little to no oil, air frying reduces the number of unhealthy fats in your food while still giving you that crispy texture you crave.

Another benefit is the faster cooking time – I can prepare meals in half the time compared to traditional oven baking or stove-top cooking.

Plus, with its versatile cooking options, I can cook just about anything from chicken wings to veggies.

In addition to being healthier and faster, air fryers offer convenience regarding meal prep.

With their compact size and ability to cook multiple items simultaneously, I use my air fryer more often than larger appliances like ovens or stovetops.

Not only does this save me time in meal preparation but also on clean up since there’s less mess involved overall because nothing sticks due to its non-stick surface!

Cons: Limited Cooking Capacity, Uneven Results, Cleaning Requirements

One downside of using an air fryer is its limited cooking capacity.

Most models are designed to cook food in small batches, which can be a hassle when preparing meals for larger groups or families.

Additionally, some users report uneven cooking results with air fryers, mainly if cooked food isn’t appropriately arranged on the cooking surface.

Another common complaint about air fryers is their cleaning requirements.

While most models have removable components that make cleanup more accessible, combining high heat and oil sprays can result in stubborn stains and buildup, requiring extra elbow grease.

Air fryers offer healthier cooking options and faster cook times than toaster ovens.

Still, they may not be suitable for every home chef due to their limited capacity and potential cleaning challenges.

However, those who value convenience and flavor may find them worthwhile investments despite these downsides.

Pros And Cons Of Using A Toaster Oven

Toaster ovens offer more cooking capacity and even cooking results, making them versatile and multi-functional appliances; however, they have longer cooking times, are less healthy of an option, and tend to consume higher energy.

Pros: More Cooking Capacity, Even Cooking Results, Multi-functional Appliance

As someone who enjoys cooking for family and friends, having a kitchen appliance with more cooking capacity is essential.

A toaster oven offers just that, making it an excellent option for those who like to entertain or cook in larger quantities.

Additionally, the even heating technology of a toaster oven ensures that every inch of your meal is cooked evenly, which can be especially important when preparing baked goods and roasts.

Another advantage of using a toaster oven is its multi-functional capabilities.

Beyond toasting bread or reheating pizza, many modern models offer cooking functions such as baking, broiling, roasting, and even air frying.

This versatility makes it easier to prepare entire meals without turning on your full-size oven or using multiple appliances at once – saving you both time and energy!

Cons: Longer Cooking Times, Less Healthy Cooking Options, Higher Energy Usage

One of the major cons of using a toaster oven is that it tends to have longer cooking times than an air fryer.

This is mainly because toaster ovens use traditional heating elements, which take time to heat up and cook food evenly.

Additionally, some foods won’t come out as crispy or evenly cooked in a toaster oven compared to an air fryer.

Another drawback of a toaster oven is that it isn’t always the healthiest cooking option.

Since they use conventional heating elements, you sometimes need more oil or butter for better taste, increasing calorie intake.

On top of that, since these appliances typically require preheating for best results, this ultimately ends up being energy inefficient.

Which Should You Choose?

After evaluating your cooking needs, kitchen space, and budget, you can decide whether to choose an air fryer or a toaster oven for your home.

Read on to learn more about these appliances and which suits your lifestyle best.

Consider Cooking Needs And Habits

When deciding between an air fryer and a toaster oven, it’s essential to think about your cooking needs and habits.

For those who enjoy healthy cooking options, the air fryer might be the better choice since it requires little to no oil for crispy results.

However, a toaster oven may be more helpful if you love baking or toasting bread frequently.

Another thing to consider is your meal preparation routine. If you typically cook small portions or single servings at a time, then an air fryer with limited capacity may suffice.

But if you often host dinner parties or have a large family to serve regularly, then the toaster oven’s more significant cooking surface area could come in handy.

Ultimately, it boils down to what works best for you based on how often you use these appliances and for what purposes.

Take into account your day-to-day habits and priorities when comparing features and prices so that you can make an informed decision that fits seamlessly into your lifestyle.

Evaluate Kitchen Space

When deciding between an air fryer and a toaster oven, it’s essential to consider the amount of kitchen space you have available.

Air Fryers are smaller and take up less counter space than a traditional toaster ovens.

However, some toaster ovens have features like convection cooking that allow for even heating and faster cooking times.

If your kitchen is on the smaller side, an air fryer may be better for you.

Its compact size allows for easy storage in small spaces when not in use. But if space isn’t a significant concern, a toaster oven could provide additional cooking options like baking and toasting.

Ultimately, evaluating your kitchen space will help you determine which appliance will fit best into your home and lifestyle.

Consider factors such as countertop surface area or available cabinet storage before deciding.

Compare Features And Prices

When choosing between an air fryer and a toaster oven, it is essential to consider each appliance’s features and prices.

Air fryers typically have smaller cooking capacities than toaster ovens but offer health benefits such as oilless cooking.

Toaster ovens may take longer to cook food, but they offer more versatility with multiple cooking functions such as baking and broiling.

It is also essential to compare the prices of both appliances, as air fryers tend to be more costly due to their newer technology.

Evaluating your kitchen space before deciding which appliance fits best in your home is advisable.

If you have limited countertop space, an air fryer might be a better option for you with its compact design.

However, if you frequently cook larger meals or host gatherings, a toaster oven with a bigger internal capacity is likely the better choice.

Both appliances are energy-efficient options; however, it’s always wise to consider energy consumption when making these decisions.

Conclusion And Recommendation

In conclusion, deciding between an air fryer and a toaster oven ultimately comes down to your personal cooking needs and habits.

An air fryer may be your best bet if you’re looking for a healthier cooking option with faster cooking times and versatile options.

However, a toaster oven might be the way to go if you need more cooking capacity, even results, and multi-functional capabilities.

When evaluating which appliance to choose, consider kitchen space, heating technology, and energy consumption, and compare features and prices.

As always, there are pros and cons associated with each appliance, but after careful consideration of what works best for your household, make an informed choice that matches your culinary goals.

Whether it’s oil-less frying or high-heat broiling – make sure to select a countertop appliance that suits your style to achieve crispy food textures while at the same time making healthy choices for yourself and your family members.

About the author

Latest posts

  • Best Chefs Knife Under 50

    Looking for that perfect chef’s knife, but the bank account is giving you a hard side-eye? Trust me, I’ve been down that road too! After digging deep into the world of kitchen cutlery (and slicing through way too many cliche knives), I uncovered some hidden gems. In this blog post, we’re going to delve into…

    Read more

  • Best Cutting Board For Japanese Knives

    Are you grappling with maintaining the razor-like sharpness of your Japanese knife on a regular cutting board? You’re not alone. It’s common knowledge amongst culinary enthusiasts that Japanese knives aren’t just everyday blades; they’re meticulously crafted works of art begging for appropriate care. The right cutting board can truly be a game-changer in preserving their…

    Read more

  • Best Blenders For Pureeing Food

    Ever had those moments where your kitchen blender just seems to give up when it comes to pureeing food? Believe me, I get how frustrating that can be. After spending many hours researching and assessing countless models available today, I’ve unearthed some truly stellar blenders. These champs, like the Vitamix E310 Explorian Blender and Ninja…

    Read more

Available for Amazon Prime