Baking sheet alternatives that might surprise you

“As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.”

There are plenty of ways to replace the baking sheet. The most readily available is aluminum foil, which we all have at home. Other alternatives are a cookie sheet, cast iron pan, baking glassware, or a silicone mat. 

We need a large enough surface that conducts heat well and can withstand high heat for a long time. In addition to the baking sheet alternatives mentioned above, we can also use things like a pizza stone or a silicone mold. 

Each alternative has its advantages and problems. Let’s take a closer look at each of them.

AmazonCommercial Heavy Duty Aluminum Foil, 12" X 500'

Aluminum foil

One of the most common materials in every home. We use it to cover bowls or pack sandwiches. But if it is strong enough, we can also use it for baking. 

The procedure is simple. We have to make a baking tray out of aluminum foil. This is done by putting several layers over each other and folding them several times (at least once) to form the shape of a baking sheet.

The aluminum foil should be used for one-time baking.  

I would not recommend using such a substitute repeatedly or too often because it may release dangerous substances into your food. You don’t want to get sick. 

But for critical situations, it is quite ideal because it is readily available and inexpensive. 

Suppose you don’t have aluminum foil at home. In that case, I’d personally recommend going for the thick and firm option like Rhino aluminum foil from Amazon.

Can I use aluminum foil instead of a baking sheet?

You can, if you stick with the following rules:

  • Try to use a heavy and thick aluminum foil
  • Always place food on the shiny side
  • Be sure that the food is not sticking – use oil or fat
  • Make sure that you create a rim around to prevent the juices from leaking out

Cookie sheet

A baking sheet and a cookie sheet are pretty much the same things. The slight difference is in the construction, where the cookie sheet does not have side rails. This fact provides more space for the cookies and, at the same time, easier handling. 

You don’t have to struggle with getting the food out of a baking sheet with a cookie sheet. Slide the content down from the cookie sheet, and that is it. 

As a replacement for a baking sheet, it is almost ideal. I say this because of the missing side rails. 

If you bake anything with a sauce or the possibility to leak, you run the risk of that happening with a cookie sheet. 

The great advantage of this substitute is that the cookie sheet has a solid base, so it can’t get tilted to one side, and your goodies won’t fall off. 

Having at least one cookie sheet at home is never a bad idea. I can recommend this one from Amazon.

Cast Iron Skillet with Lid - 12"-inch Pre-Seasoned Covered Frying Pan Set + Silicone Handle & Lid Holders + Scraper/Cleaner - Indoor/Outdoor, Oven, Stovetop, Camping Fire, Grill Safe Kitchen Cookware

Cast iron pan

Cast iron is one of the most rigid materials to cook with. It can be a challenge to pick it up or work with it in general. Cast iron pan is a great but challenging alternative. Literally.

Aside from the weight of the material itself, there are only benefits. The main one is excellent thermal conductivity. Cast iron heats up very quickly and evenly to the desired temperature. It, therefore, allows problem-free baking of any recipe. 

Another benefit is the fact that cast iron can release iron during use. In the case of other materials, this could be a problem, but in this case, it is an advantage. You can get a small dose of extra iron in your diet in a natural way, which does not harm you. 

A minor disadvantage of this alternative to the baking sheet, besides the weight, may be a tiny size. The bigger a cast iron pan is, the heavier it gets. So it is not very suitable for daily baking. 

If you opt for this alternative to the baking sheet, make sure that your oven rack can hold not only the iron pan itself but also its contents. 

I have had the misfortune of not checking this and finding my oven rack bent into a V shape. The entire dish was spilled over the oven, as the shelf could not support the weight. 

By the way, I recently got this great cast iron pot and pans set from my mother-in-law on Amazon, and I am more than happy with it. I believe cast iron cookware is an excellent asset to any cook who is at least a little serious about cooking. 

Baking glassware

I originally wanted to talk about Pyrex glassware here. Still, there seems to have been a change in manufacturing in recent years, and many of the company’s products tend to explode when used. For this reason, I can only recommend general baking glassware. 

If you have an old-school Pyrex from your grandmother’s days, you can certainly use it as a replacement for a baking sheet. These old pieces were made when everything was correctly constructed, and they have lasted until now. 

Anyway, baking glassware is an excellent alternative to a baking sheet. It has everything you could want on a baking sheet. 

Ample space, high sides, good thermal conductivity, and last but not least, you can see through it, which is especially useful if you are baking anything that looks nice. 

The only thing you have to consider is the slightly higher weight. It’s not as bad as a cast iron pan, but the overall weight is still higher than a baking sheet. 

Use the rule of thumb here and do not pile everything on to create a vast mountain. 

If you lack baking glassware at home that you can rely on, you should check out this set. I believe you won’t go wrong with it.

Silicone baking mat

Although it is ideal to use a silicone baking mat in conjunction with a baking sheet, this does not mean that it cannot be used alone in a situation of extreme emergency. It is just good to keep in mind that it is a thin material that bends easily. On this basis, the silicone baking mat should be supported by at least an oven rack.

Otherwise, it is almost identical to a cookie sheet in terms of ease of handling. Its great advantage is its low weight, which allows easy handling. 

You will find a silicone baking mat for every occasion. The silicone baking mat is sure to be enjoyed in the home and is always handy to have on hand. At the same time, it is better to have fewer things of higher quality than a lot of lower quality stuff, so I dare to recommend this set.

Vojta Vevera

Combining a love for cooking and using all kinds of technological gizmos helps Vojta to bring the experiences and excitement to all his articles. He is always doing his best to serve you with great information. Mixing over 15 years of cooking experience with his analytical mind and love for all technological things.

Recent Posts