Comparing Air Fryer vs Convection Toaster Oven: Which Is Right for You?




Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

Navigating the sea of kitchen gadgets that promise to transform your home cooking can sometimes feel like a culinary odyssey. Trust me, I’ve navigated these waters, caught in the crossfire of persuasive product features and impassioned customer testimonials.

My journey across kitchens—whether coaxing flavors out of slow-cooked stews or mastering the artful crispiness achieved by frying—has taught me one essential truth: selecting the quintessential tool can make or break your gastronomic quest.

The battle royale between air fryers and convection toaster ovens is one such epicurean puzzle – with each contender brandishing its own arsenal of features.

Enter air fryers, celebrated champions of crunch that turn out golden treats using but a whisper of oil compared to traditional methods. But let’s not overlook convection toaster ovens – those multitasking marvels that blend countertop convenience with astonishing adaptability.

Envision baking sumptuous cakes, broiling savory dishes, and yes—even ‘air-frying’ without needing separate gadgets jockeying for space on your counter! This article aims to be more than just a side-by-side comparison; it’s meant as a guiding light through the dense thicket of kitchen gadgetry decisions.

Journey through these paragraphs for insights sharp enough to rival any kitchen blade—and uncover which appliance will reign supreme in the epic saga of your home cuisine!

Key Takeaways

  • Air fryers cook food quickly with little oil, making them good for crispy snacks. They are small and easy to clean, perfect for tight kitchens.
  • Convection toaster ovens bake, broil, and toast as well as air fry. They have a larger cooking area but take up more space on the countertop.
  • When choosing between an air fryer and convection toaster oven, think about your kitchen size, what foods you like to cook, how fast you want meals ready, and if you want one appliance that does multiple things.
  • Both appliances need regular cleaning; baskets in air fryers can often go in the dishwasher while convection ovens might have crumb trays to help with messes.
  • Testing out different recipes in each appliance helps figure out which one works best for your cooking style.

Understanding Air Fryers and Convection Toaster Ovens

Air fryers and convection toaster ovens are both countertop cooking appliances that use circulating hot air to cook food. They have different sizes, benefits, and limitations. If you want to know more about the types of air fryers, their benefits and limitations as well as the types of convection toaster ovens, keep reading for more details!

Types of Air Fryers

I’m diving into the world of air fryers to help you understand the options. Air fryers come in different shapes and sizes, each with unique features.

  • Basket Air Fryers: These have a removable basket where you place your food. You slide the basket into the unit, set the temperature, and cooking starts. It’s easy to shake food for even cooking.
  • Oven Air Fryers: Oven-style models look like mini ovens with shelves. They give you more space to cook several items at once. Plus, they often include rotisserie functions.
  • Paddle-Type Air Fryers: With these, a built-in paddle stirs your food. This means less manual shaking and turning over of ingredients for even cooking.
  • Digital Air Fryers: These offer touch-screen controls instead of dials. They provide precise temperature and time settings for accurate cooking.

Benefits and Limitations

Now let’s delve into the benefits and limitations of air fryers and convection toaster ovens. Air fryers offer the advantage of producing crispy, golden brown results with significantly less oil than traditional frying methods, making them a healthier option for enjoying your favorite fried foods.

However, they are relatively small in size, which may limit the quantity of food you can cook at once. On the other hand, convection toaster ovens provide a more spacious cooking area that can accommodate larger food items or greater quantities.

Yet, they may not achieve the same level of crispiness as air fryers due to their less powerful convection settings.

In terms of convenience, air fryers excel in cooking speed by preparing meals faster than conventional ovens or even convection toaster ovens. This makes them an ideal choice for individuals with busy schedules looking to enjoy delicious meals without spending too much time in the kitchen.

Types of Convection Toaster Ovens

Convection toaster ovens come in various types, each offering unique features and cooking capabilities.

  1. Compact convection toaster ovens are suitable for small kitchens or individuals with limited countertop space. They are portable and energy-efficient, making them ideal for quick meals or snacks.
  2. Large capacity convection toaster ovens provide ample space for cooking multiple dishes at once, making them perfect for families or those who frequently entertain guests.
  3. Premium convection toaster ovens boast advanced features such as digital controls, multiple cooking functions, and precision temperature settings, allowing for precise and versatile cooking options.
  4. Budget – friendly convection toaster ovens offer basic functionalities while being affordable and accessible to a wide range of home cooks.
  5. Combination convection toaster ovens integrate additional cooking methods such as air frying, broiling, or dehydrating, providing versatility in preparing a variety of recipes without the need for multiple appliances.
  6. Multi – rack convection toaster ovens feature adjustable racks or shelves, allowing users to customize the cooking space according to their specific needs and culinary creations.

Key Differences between Air Fryers and Convection Toaster Ovens

Air fryers are typically smaller and more compact than convection toaster ovens, making them ideal for tight kitchen spaces. They also tend to cook food faster due to their high-speed air circulation technology.

However, convection toaster ovens offer a wider range of cooking options and can be used for baking, broiling, and toasting in addition to air frying.


Air fryers have a smaller footprint, taking up less space on the countertop compared to convection toaster ovens. The compact size makes it ideal for kitchens with limited space, perfect for small apartments or crowded countertops.

On the other hand, convection toaster ovens are larger in size and require more counter space, but they can also hold more food at once.

Considering kitchen real estate is key when choosing between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven. If you have limited space or cook for one or two people, the small footprint of an air fryer might be more practical.

Ease of Use

Air fryers are simple to use, requiring minimal preheating and cooking time. Their compact size makes them easy to store and clean. Additionally, most air fryer baskets and trays are dishwasher safe, making cleanup a breeze.

Convection toaster ovens, on the other hand, may take up more counter space but offer additional cooking functions such as baking and broiling. Some users find them versatile for various cooking needs due to their larger interior capacity compared to standard air fryers.

In terms of ease of use, both appliances have their advantages – air fryers excel in quick and efficient cooking with little maintenance required, while convection toaster ovens provide versatility for a wider range of cooking methods but may require more storage space.


Air fryers offer great versatility, allowing for not only frying but also baking, grilling, and roasting. They can handle a wide range of foods like meats, vegetables, and even desserts.

On the other hand, convection toaster ovens provide similar versatility by offering multiple cooking functions such as toasting, baking, broiling, and warming. This makes them suitable for preparing various dishes and accommodating different cooking needs without taking up extra space in the kitchen.

The larger capacity of air-fryer toaster ovens provides more flexibility to cook larger quantities at once or accommodate bigger food items like whole chickens or pizzas compared to standard air fryers or convection toaster ovens.

Cooking Options

Air fryers offer the option to make crispy foods with little to no oil, while convection toaster ovens provide a wider range of cooking techniques such as baking, broiling, and roasting.

Air fryers are great for making healthier versions of fried foods like chicken wings and french fries. On the other hand, convection toaster ovens excel at evenly cooking larger items like whole chickens or pizzas.

With an air fryer, I can quickly whip up some crunchy snacks without using much oil; however, my convection toaster oven gives me the flexibility to cook a variety of meals with consistent results.

When considering the cooking options between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven, it’s essential to assess whether you prefer quick and healthy snacks or desire a broader range of culinary possibilities in your kitchen routine.

Cooking Speed

Air fryers cook food faster than a conventional oven, which is great for busy cooks. They use powerful fans to circulate hot air, cooking the food rapidly and evenly. This quick cooking time can be helpful when you need to get dinner on the table fast or want a healthy snack in minutes.

Convection toaster ovens also offer fast cooking times due to their efficient heat distribution. The convection setting helps reduce overall cooking time by circulating hot air around the food.

This means you can enjoy crispy and delicious dishes without waiting too long. So, whether it’s your favorite snacks or a full meal, both appliances promise speedy results that fit into your busy schedule.

Cleaning and Maintenance

To maintain an air fryer or convection toaster oven, regularly clean the removable parts with warm soapy water. Detachable components like the basket and tray should be scrubbed to remove any food residue.

Do not immerse these parts in water as they may contain electrical elements. Wipe the interior and exterior of the appliance with a damp cloth after each use to prevent grease buildup.

Ensure proper ventilation by keeping the appliance’s vents clear of debris and oil accumulation.

When cooking greasy foods, consider lining the bottom tray with aluminum foil or parchment paper to catch drips and reduce cleanup time. For convection ovens, periodically check and clean the fan blades if accessible for optimal performance.

Which Countertop Oven is Right for You?

Consider your cooking needs, space constraints, and budget to decide between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven. To learn more about the pros and cons of each countertop oven option, keep reading!

Considerations for Choosing

When choosing between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven, consider the following factors:

  1. Size matters: The space available in your kitchen and the quantity of food you typically cook will dictate whether an air fryer or convection toaster oven is more suitable for your needs.
  2. Cooking speed: If you need quick meals, an air fryer’s rapid cooking time may be more convenient for your busy schedule.
  3. Versatility: Consider the range of foods you want to cook. Convection toaster ovens can handle a wider variety of cooking techniques, from baking to broiling, while air fryers are best suited for crispy, fried-style dishes.
  4. Crispy results: If achieving that golden crispy texture is a priority for you, an air fryer may be the better option due to its specialized frying capabilities.
  5. Budget and cost-effectiveness: Assessing the initial cost as well as long-term energy use can help determine which option suits your financial constraints and efficiency goals.
  6. Maintenance: Cleaning and upkeep play a crucial role in appliance satisfaction. Factor in ease of cleaning when making your decision.
  7. Space-saving: For those with limited countertop space, an air fryer’s compact size could be a deciding factor compared to a bulkier convection toaster oven.

Air Fryer vs Convection Toaster Oven

Now that we’ve considered what to keep in mind when choosing between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven, let’s dive into the comparison of these two popular kitchen appliances.

FeatureAir FryerConvection Toaster Oven
FootprintGenerally smaller and more compactLarger, offering more cooking surface area
Ease of UseSimple interfaces, often just time and temperature controlsMore settings and functions may require a learning curve
VersatilityPrimarily used for air frying, with some models offering additional featuresCapable of baking, broiling, toasting, and sometimes rotisserie cooking
Cooking OptionsFocused on crispy and evenly cooked resultsMore variety with the ability to handle different cooking methods
Cooking SpeedTends to cook food faster due to the rapid air circulationMay take longer but can cook more food at once
Cleaning and MaintenanceUsually features non-stick baskets that are dishwasher safeMay have more parts to clean but often come with crumb trays for easy cleanup

Deciding between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven depends greatly on your cooking style and needs. If you value quick and crispy meals, an air fryer might be your best bet. On the other hand, for those who appreciate diverse cooking functions and larger meal preparations, a convection toaster oven is a versatile choice. Keep these comparisons in mind as you decide which countertop oven will suit your kitchen best.

Tips for Cooking with a Convection Toaster Oven

When using a convection toaster oven, it’s important to cut your food into similar-sized pieces, arrange them in a single layer for even cooking, increase airflow by using perforated pans or spacing out items, don’t skip the oil as it helps with crispiness, preheat your oven properly, and try convection bake first for optimal results.

To learn more about maximizing your cooking potential with a convection toaster oven, read on!

Cut Pieces to Same Size

For even cooking, cut ingredients into uniform sizes to ensure they cook at the same rate. This helps everything get golden brown and crispy in an air fryer or convection toaster oven.

Additionally, evenly sized pieces ensure that your food will be uniformly cooked, providing a consistent texture and taste throughout.

Achieving uniformity in size allows for even circulation of hot air around all the pieces during cooking. In turn, this results in perfectly cooked dishes with a deliciously crispy exterior and tender interior.

Arrange Food in a Single Layer

When arranging food in the convection toaster oven or air fryer, it’s crucial to lay the items in a single layer. This ensures even cooking and allows the hot air to circulate around each piece, resulting in crispier and more evenly cooked food.

Overcrowding may prevent proper airflow, leading to uneven browning and longer cooking times.

The importance of this step cannot be overstated when seeking that desired crispy texture from your air-fried or convection-cooked meals. By adhering to this simple practice, you can elevate the quality of your dishes and make the most out of your kitchen equipment.

Increase Airflow

To ensure that your food cooks evenly and crisps up nicely, it’s essential to increase airflow in your air fryer or convection toaster oven. This can be done by not overcrowding the cooking area, allowing enough space between food items for hot air to circulate.

In an air fryer, using perforated parchment paper liners or wire racks can also help promote better airflow around the food, resulting in a crispier texture. When using a convection toaster oven, placing a wire rack inside the baking pan and utilizing the convection setting will enhance airflow and achieve more consistent results.

Now let’s delve into “Don’t Skip the Oil” for successful cooking in both appliances.

Don’t Skip the Oil

Oil is crucial in cooking with convection toaster ovens. It enhances the texture and flavor of your food, helping it to crisp up nicely. I recommend using oils with high smoke points like canola or avocado oil for best results in your convection toaster oven.

Be mindful not to overdo the oil as it may lead to excessive smoking or uneven cooking. When prepping your ingredients, lightly coat them with a thin layer of oil before placing them in the oven for that perfect crunch.

Now let’s delve into some handy tips for effective usage and maintenance of your countertop oven.

Proper Preheating

For proper preheating, set the toaster oven or air fryer to the recommended temperature. This ensures that food cooks evenly and thoroughly. Preheating saves time and energy by allowing the appliance to reach the desired cooking temperature before adding food.

Proper preheating is vital for achieving crispy and delicious results when using an air fryer or convection toaster oven. It helps in making your meals golden brown and evenly cooked without consuming too much energy.

Try Convection Bake First

When using a convection toaster oven, start by trying the convection bake setting to experience even cooking and faster results. This setting uses a fan to circulate hot air, ensuring that your food is cooked thoroughly and evenly.

The convection bake feature can help achieve crispy textures on foods like roasted vegetables and chicken wings without the need for excessive oil, making it a healthier cooking option.

It’s also beneficial for baking, providing consistent browning and rising for cakes and cookies.

Final Verdict on Air Fryer vs Convection Toaster Oven

After testing various recipes and considering the advice of popular chefs, it’s clear that both the air fryer and convection toaster oven have their own strengths. However, our reader recipe for crispy soy curls in a convection toaster oven may just sway your decision in favor of this versatile countertop appliance.

Recipe Tests

I tried making crispy sweet potato fries in both an air fryer and a convection toaster oven. The air fryer produced slightly crispier results in a shorter time. When I made homemade chicken nuggets, the convection toaster oven cooked them more evenly and was able to accommodate a larger batch at once.

Using each appliance for different recipes helped me understand their strengths better.

Experimenting with various recipes like mozzarella sticks or vegetable fritters will provide you with valuable insights into the performance of both appliances. Testing different dishes is essential to see which one suits your cooking style and preferences best.

Considerations from Popular Chefs

As a chef who has extensively used both air fryers and convection toaster ovens, I can confidently say that each appliance brings its own unique benefits to the table. When considering which one is right for you, think about the type of food you frequently cook.

Air fryers are excellent for achieving crispy results with minimal oil, making them ideal for cooking frozen foods and achieving a deep-fried texture without the excessive oil. On the other hand, convection toaster ovens offer more versatility in terms of baking, roasting, and broiling thanks to their spacious interior and adjustable racks.

It’s important to consider your specific cooking needs when deciding between these two appliances.

Popular chefs often lean towards air fryers due to their ability to quickly produce crispy textures while using less oil than traditional frying methods. However, many also appreciate the versatility of convection toaster ovens for their larger capacity and ability to handle various cooking methods beyond just air frying.

Reader Recipe: Crispy Soy Curls in a Convection Toaster Oven

I made crispy soy curls in my convection toaster oven, and they turned out delicious! I marinated the soy curls in a savory sauce, then spread them out on the baking tray. With the convection setting, they cooked evenly and became wonderfully crisp without needing to deep-fry.

The result was perfectly golden-brown and crunchy soy curls that were healthy and satisfying. This recipe showcases how versatile a convection toaster oven can be for creating healthier versions of favorite dishes.


In conclusion, the choice between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven ultimately depends on personal cooking needs and preferences. The summary of key differences in footprint, ease of use, versatility, cooking options, speed, cleaning, and maintenance offers practical insights.

Have you considered which appliance aligns better with your lifestyle? Embrace these tips for efficient cooking with your selected countertop oven. The impact of selecting the right appliance can significantly improve your cooking experience.

Explore further resources or guidance to enhance your culinary journey. Make an informed decision that will revolutionize your at-home cooking routine.

– Which Is Better for Cooking Food Quickly: Air Fryer or Microwave?

When it comes to cooking food quickly, the debate of air fryer versus microwave is a hot topic. While microwaves are great for reheating leftovers and cooking certain dishes, air fryers use hot air to cook food, giving it a crispy texture without the need for oil, making it a healthier option.


1. What’s the difference between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven?

The main difference is that an air fryer cooks food by circulating hot air around it, while a convection toaster oven has a fan to spread heat evenly for baking and roasting.

2. Which is better for healthy cooking: an air fryer or a convection toaster oven?

Both can be good for healthy cooking because they use less oil than traditional frying, but an air fryer might be slightly better as it’s designed to mimic deep-frying without much fat.

3. Can you do air frying with a convection toaster oven?

Yes, you can use the convection setting on your toaster oven which moves hot air around like in an air fryer, so it works well for recipes that call for air frying.

4. Is there a big difference in energy usage between an air fryer and a convection toaster oven?

An air fryer typically uses less energy because it heats up quicker due to its smaller size compared to most convection toaster ovens.

5. How do cooking times compare when using an air fryer versus a convection toaster oven?

Cooking times may differ as each appliance cooks differently; however, since both circulate hot air, meals often cook faster than in regular ovens.

About the author

Latest posts

  • Best Chefs Knife Under 50

    Looking for that perfect chef’s knife, but the bank account is giving you a hard side-eye? Trust me, I’ve been down that road too! After digging deep into the world of kitchen cutlery (and slicing through way too many cliche knives), I uncovered some hidden gems. In this blog post, we’re going to delve into…

    Read more

  • Best Cutting Board For Japanese Knives

    Are you grappling with maintaining the razor-like sharpness of your Japanese knife on a regular cutting board? You’re not alone. It’s common knowledge amongst culinary enthusiasts that Japanese knives aren’t just everyday blades; they’re meticulously crafted works of art begging for appropriate care. The right cutting board can truly be a game-changer in preserving their…

    Read more

  • Best Blenders For Pureeing Food

    Ever had those moments where your kitchen blender just seems to give up when it comes to pureeing food? Believe me, I get how frustrating that can be. After spending many hours researching and assessing countless models available today, I’ve unearthed some truly stellar blenders. These champs, like the Vitamix E310 Explorian Blender and Ninja…

    Read more

Available for Amazon Prime